Comparative Critical Analysis Handout

Abstract

ENGL 300 – Advanced Composition The Comparative Critical Analysis Essay This assignment is based on the course readings on which shorter critical reading assignments have been completed. You are required to select two of these readings and do a critical assessment in which you compare the two along specific lines that you articulate clearly within a well-crafted thesis. The objective here is two-fold: Firstly, select two readings that you find most compelling and interesting and formulate your topic around these articles. Secondly, identify and explain in a brief summary the argument that the respective authors make Thirdly, provide your own evaluative thesis regarding the arguments and the methods (strategies) employed in making their respective arguments. Fourthly, engage a thoroughgoing examination of the work within this focused framework, doing a comparative analysis of the ideas, form, structure etc. of the two works with the chief focus being to point out the synergies, dissimilarities with respect to central argument, perspectives, audience, strategies, etc. Ultimately, this assignment requires you to analyze, evaluate, and synthesize material. Provide a title for your essay. Articles for Consideration “Uncovering the Bahamian Self” by Patricia Glinton Meicholas “National Identity and Bahamian Culture” by Howard Johnson “Goin’ Back to Da Island” by Ian Strachan “Junkanoo, Territory and Identity” by Nicolette Bethel “Migrations” by Patricia Glinton Meicholas Some Points to Consider: What is the author’s central thesis/argument? For what purpose is s/he writing this piece? To which audience (specific and general) is this article directed? How appropriate are language choices in relation to the intended audience? Is the author’s argument consistent throughout the article? What particular strategies are most effective in making the ideas clear and the argument compelling? Does the author’s evidence support his/her argument? Is the evidence credible? How does the use of tone affect the way the...